جستجوی مقالات مرتبط با کلیدواژه "قاعده منع تعقیب مجدد عمودی" در نشریات گروه "فقه و حقوق"

With the advent of international criminal court and tribunals, there are ne bis in idem provisions that restrict both the international and national courts in conducting subsequent prosecutions. Ne bis in idem rule can apply both horizontally and vertically. However, the function of latter is adjusting the relationship between international courts and national courts. The vertical ne bis in idem effect includes both "downward" and "upward" levels. The content and scope of the rule are not uniformly defined. In particular, ways to interpret the two decisive factors ‘Idem’ and ‘Bis’ vary considerably. In the interpretation of the term “Idem”, there is the ambiguity as to what stage former prosecution should be taken place in order to prevent a new prosecution. Another ambiguity relates to the term “Bis”; In fact, what is the Bis and in which circumstances second prosecution is double prosecution. Response to that depends on the test that is used by the court: the same conduct test or the same offence test. This paper by examining statutes and case law of international criminal court and tribunals concludes that former prosecution had to give rise to conviction or acquittal to prevent new trial. Depending on the upward or downward vertical Ne Bis in Idem rule, application of both tests is possible.