Judicial precedent criticism: Requirement to recruit scholars admitted

Sending students abroad (scholarship) were conducted according to the executive regulation of law governing of sending the students abroad by holding a exam until 2004. Between 2006 and 2008, the condition for the exam was removed and with changing the regulations, other criteria for the selecting volunteers for sending abroad are legislated. According to the Court of Auditor's report in 2013, some of these changes were not legal and also the some rules are not correctly implemented in the same way for those who were accepted.The verdict that follows, is analyzed and criticized, refers to one of the scholars admitted whose after graduation, for employment at a university in which he was already located has filled a lawsuit in the Administrative Court of Justice. After reviewing the case, the court has ordered the issue out of time that the admission and placement of the volunteers of the scholarship means the obligation of the scholarship provider to hire them after the completion of the scholarship. While this inference is not consistent with the legal principles, laws and regulations governing the employment and recruitment of applicants to the faculty membership of universities and educational and research institutes.