A Critical Review of the Book:Imaginative Hadiths in Majma al - Bayan

The compiler of the book Imaginative Hadiths holds that hadiths in Tafsir of Majma al – Bayan ascribed to are not of Imam Baqir and they are Tabari,s tafsir views.since Shaykh Tusi calls Tabari s tafsir views as Abujafar and after his demis writers of Tibyan thought that Abujafar is the same as Imam Baqir, thus this is the point that misled the writer of Majmaal – Bayan to ascribe these hadith to Imam Baqir.The author of this paper disagrees with the above – mentioned opinion and believes that Abujafar is the same Imam Baqir. To prove this, he presents some other evidences.