Review of the Shadiabadi Commentary on Khaghani's Poems

Difficulty is a feature that has always been attributed to Khaghani's poems, and since old times, various commentaries have been written for their analysis. One of the ancient commentaries of this divan is the one by Shadiabadi, which also has a remarkable scientific value. Recently, for the first time, this commentary has been edited and published by Khosrow Shahabi. Despite the efforts of the editor, due to the lack of observing the principles and standards of scientific and critical editing, various shortcomings and flaws can be seen in the text. In this article, we will explain these problems.