ypology and evaluation of critiques of contemporary Shiite commentators on the views of Allameh Tabatabai (Case study of Surah Al-Baqarah)

Message:
Article Type:
Case Study (دارای رتبه معتبر)
Abstract:

Allameh Tabatabai's views have been widely reflected and have had a significant impact on contemporary Shiite Quranic works. Of course, contemporary Shiite commentators, in addition to widely using the views of the author of Al-Mizan, have also examined and criticized his views in significant cases. Leading research that has been done by descriptive-analytical method and using library tools, by studying contemporary interpretive works, explores and extracts the arguments of commentators in criticizing the views of Al-Mizan author (about the verses of Surah Al-Baqarah) and evaluates them. Some commentators have criticized Allameh's views in cases such as: what are the syllables, discovering the meanings of Quranic words, determining the instances of Quranic words and phrases, explaining the meaning and contents of verses. The most important reasons cited by critics are: vague reading, know the opposite, incompatibility with Qur'anic sources and narration, consider weak and invalid, incorrect and unprovable, contradiction with the meaning of verses, incompatibility with Qur'anic evidences and verses, lack of meaning of the verse on interpretation, etc. after reviewing and evaluating the opinions of critics, the results of the research show that most of these criticisms are invalid and face major harms and problems. Of course, in a few cases, the opinions of critics are correct and valid, and the weakness of Allameh's views is accepted. Of course, in a few cases, the opinions of the critics are valid and the weakness of Allameh's views is accepted.

Language:
Persian
Published:
Journal of Qur'anic Knowledge, Volume:13 Issue: 49, 2022
Pages:
29 to 62
https://magiran.com/p2457010  
مقالات دیگری از این نویسنده (گان)